TEARS FOR PARENTS – FORENSIC RESEARCH ON THE CHILDCARE SECTOR

UK Nursery sector risks being damaged by large corporate takeovers

Smaller nurseries in England are being bought up by profit-focused companies, without necessarily creating more places or investing more in staff, according to a major new study led by UCL researchers. I have personally been involved over several years in writing and researching this report, with this top team of researchers, and would like to share key findings. My focus has been on the financial analysis of the nurseries and their audited accounts, to understand the links between finance and care. Given children’s development is key to building a sustainable society, it is so important that their early years care is affordable and of a high quality, ensuring that the staff are well paid, and parents are not exploited. As the government is a key funder of the sector, public money should also be well-used and the UN Sustainable Developments goals of quality child education and development need to be met by the nursery providers. Private nursery chains need to act responsibly and pay their relevant taxes in return for the government subsidy. For busy working parents, what happens behind the scenes will tell the full story of the culture & primary objectives of these.

Links to the report:

• Main report: https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10142357/
• Technical annex: https://discovery.ucl.ac.uk/id/eprint/10142358/

The report, published today and funded by the Nuffield Foundation, charts changes in early years childcare provision over the past two decades. It shows that large private-for-profit companies are heavily indebted, and their risky financial operating models could threaten the provision of nursery places.

The nursery sector is at threat of being damaged in the same way the adult social care sector has been, with care home providers having to close down at short notice.

As part of the study, we carried out interviews and surveys with around 80 nurseries. This included in-depth investigations of the financial operation for five medium to large private-for-profit nursery groups and six not-for-profit nursery groups.

The authors say the findings are ‘very concerning’, given that the UK Government contributes an estimated £5.6 billion in funds and subsidies to support early years childcare and education in England.

Antonia Simon (IOE, UCL’s Faculty of Education and Society), Associate Professor and lead author of the report, explained: “Many of the companies that are able to buy up parts of the nursery sector, because of the government’s funding model, are heavily reliant on private equity funding and have growing debts and low to negative operating reserves, placing such provision at risk of collapse.

“The complex financial structures of these companies involve foreign investors and shareholders which are used, alongside public money, to expand their market share. While shareholders in the private equity companies and their senior executives’ may profit from investing in such companies, little of this money is being reinvested back into the sector.”

The findings highlight the stark contrast in the way not-for-profit childcare companies are run, with charitable nurseries supplying transparent accounts to the Charity Commission, compared to the more limited accounts larger private companies need to file with Companies House.

Not-for-profit companies cannot carry substantial debts and must also re-invest any surplus into the childcare business. The report shows that staff costs in these companies could be as much as 14% higher than in the for-profit childcare sector.

Other key findings include:

• Large ‘private- for-profit’ childcare companies are not transparent about how they spend the public money they receive. This includes the money received for government funded childcare hours and the subsidies for parental fees via tax credits or the benefits system*.

• These large childcare companies have increased their market share, without a substantial increase in childcare places. In England, private for-profit nurseries provided 707,000** childcare places (70% of all group-based nursery places) in 2021.

• Private firms charge high prices to parents, relative to other OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) countries, whilst staff qualifications are amongst the lowest. The proportion of income spent on wages is lower for the private- for-profit childcare companies than for the not-for-profit companies, with staff across the sector being poorly paid, and many paid below the national living wage.

The report makes several recommendations and calls for policymakers to review the way the sector receives public funding, and, particularly, how disadvantaged families access provision. The authors suggest childcare companies consider having representation of parents and staff on the nursery management board so thattheir interests can be best represented. The government could also consider making staff and parental involvement in the management of nurseries a condition of childcare companies receiving public funding.

The nursery sector needs to be more transparent and Ofsted should collect and publish information on who owns the nurseries including whether they are part of a chain, private, voluntary, or managed by the local authority.

Antonia Simon concluded: “If these nurseries collapse, as we have seen in the adult social care sector, children and families will miss out on vital and valuable early years care and opportunities and many nursery staff could lose their jobs. Urgent reforms must be made to the early years sector leading to greater transparency and accountability.”

“We recommend that state funding goes only to childcare companies that can provide accounting evidence that they have financial reserves and low risk of bankruptcy”.

One of the co-authors of the report Prof Eva Lloyd OBE PhD explained:

“This report provides a unique insight into the financial operations and marketing techniques of major childcare chains which increasingly dominate the English childcare market. Professor Atul Shah applied forensic accounting techniques to the analysis of publicly available childcare company data, something not done before. His analysis throws an urgently needed new light on sustainability risks threatening the early years sector. It has been a pleasure to work with him on this groundbreaking research project.”

Eleanor Ireland, Programme Head of Education, Nuffield Foundation, said: “These findings highlight the risks to the financial sustainability of private nursery provision – on which many parents and young children depend – posed by the increasing dominance of large companies that often have high levels of debt and which are not subject to the same level of accountability as voluntary and state-maintained providers. In light of the scale of public money given to these companies, there is a need to ensure it is deployed in the most effective way to provide high-quality, sustainable care for the children and families for whom it is intended.”