PROFESSOR ATUL K. SHAH www.atulkshah.co.uk
Globally renowned expert advisor and broadcaster on culture, accounting, finance, business ethics, holistic education and leadership
There is a profound paradox in modern psychology: a discipline devoted to understanding human beings has often studied them as though their minds could be separated from the cultures, histories, beliefs and communities that shape them.
Yet culture is not simply something that influences psychology. Culture helps constitute how people think, feel, remember, relate, develop moral judgement and understand themselves.
The problem is particularly acute in experimental, cognitive and some clinical traditions of psychology. Cultural, social, developmental, community and indigenous psychologists have challenged these assumptions for decades.
I would identify seven underlying reasons.
1. Psychology wants to be a universal science
Modern academic psychology developed with a strong ambition to emulate the natural sciences.
It sought general laws of human behaviour through experiments, measurement, controlled observation and statistical inference.
This encouraged psychologists to distinguish universal psychological mechanisms from supposedly secondary cultural influences.
But the difficulty is that the human mind develops within language, relationships, institutions and shared meanings.
For example, concepts such as independence, self-esteem, happiness, intelligence and personal achievement may be understood differently across societies.
The problem arises when a culturally particular understanding of the individual becomes the supposedly universal definition of human psychology.
Psychology has sometimes mistaken the psychology of a particular cultural population for the psychology of humanity.
2. The WEIRD problem: studying a minority of humanity
One of the most influential critiques was developed by Joseph Henrich, Steven Heine and Ara Norenzayan in their 2010 paper, The Weirdest People in the World?
WEIRD stands for:
- Western
- Educated
- Industrialised
- Rich
- Democratic
They demonstrated that populations commonly used in psychological experiments were often unusual compared with the wider human population across a range of psychological measures.
University students in Western societies were frequently treated as representative of human beings generally.
This has implications for research on perception, reasoning, fairness, cooperation and the self.
The critique is not that Western psychological research is worthless. It is that claims of universality require evidence from diverse populations.
3. Culture challenges psychology’s methods of measurement
Culture is difficult to capture through standardised psychological scales.
Consider trust.
A psychologist might ask respondents to rate their agreement with:
“Most people can be trusted.”
But what does trust mean?
In one context it may mean confidence in strangers. Elsewhere it may mean obligations within kinship networks, religious communities or long-standing trading relationships.
The same question can evoke different meanings.
Similarly, psychological measures of happiness may privilege individual satisfaction, whereas other traditions emphasise harmony, duty, restraint, family wellbeing or spiritual development.
This is not an argument against measurement. It is an argument for establishing conceptual and measurement equivalence before making comparisons.
Qualitative research, ethnography, interviews and cultural history can help determine whether researchers are measuring the same phenomenon across contexts.
4. Psychology inherited an individualistic understanding of the person
Much mainstream psychology begins with the individual as the primary unit of analysis.
The individual possesses attitudes, traits, beliefs, emotions, motivations and cognitive processes.
Society and culture are then introduced as influences upon that individual.
But many philosophical and cultural traditions begin from a different understanding.
The person is constituted through relationships, obligations, language, family, community, history and interdependence.
Hazel Markus and Shinobu Kitayama’s influential 1991 work on culture and the self examined independent and interdependent self-construals.
Their contribution was to demonstrate that understandings of the self can shape cognition, emotion and motivation.
However, even these categories require careful application: individuals and cultures cannot simply be divided into two fixed types.
A deeper issue remains:
Is the individual an autonomous psychological entity influenced by culture, or is personhood itself culturally and relationally constituted?
That is not merely an empirical disagreement. It is a philosophical disagreement about what a human being is.
5. Culture makes psychology’s claim to neutrality more complicated
Psychologists often aspire to objective and value-neutral knowledge.
Yet the selection of research questions, the definition of desirable outcomes and the construction of psychological categories may themselves reflect cultural assumptions.
Consider:
| Psychological concept | Cultural questions that need examining |
|---|---|
| Success | Individual achievement or contribution to others? |
| Happiness | Personal satisfaction, harmony, purpose or spiritual growth? |
| Intelligence | Abstract reasoning, practical wisdom, social judgement or self-discipline? |
| Autonomy | Independence or responsible interdependence? |
| Mental wellbeing | Individual functioning or relationships and community belonging? |
| Moral development | Universal principles, duties, compassion or cultivated character? |
This does not mean scientific objectivity is impossible.
It means that researchers must be reflexive about the cultural assumptions shaping their theories and methods.
A psychologist’s own cultural background is not automatically a source of bias, but neither is it irrelevant to the production of knowledge.
6. Culture requires interdisciplinary knowledge
To understand culture deeply, psychology must engage with anthropology, sociology, history, philosophy, religious studies, linguistics and political economy.
This can be institutionally difficult.
Academic disciplines have their own journals, training requirements, methods and professional hierarchies.
A psychologist trained primarily in experiments and statistical modelling may have limited preparation for interpreting religious narratives, community institutions, oral histories or historical traditions.
Conversely, qualitative researchers may lack the methodological tools needed to test generalisable psychological hypotheses.
Neither approach is inherently superior.
The challenge is to combine them without reducing one to the language of the other.
For example, a study of Jain business families could investigate the psychological effects of trust, restraint and intergenerational responsibility through both quantitative evidence and detailed historical and ethnographic research.
The second approach might reveal meanings that were not anticipated when the original questionnaire was designed.
7. Culture exposes the political history of psychological knowledge
Psychology developed within particular historical circumstances, including European intellectual traditions, colonial expansion, industrialisation and modern professional institutions.
Some psychological ideas were used to classify populations, justify hierarchies and support discriminatory practices.
Intelligence testing and racialised psychological theories provide particularly troubling historical examples.
However, psychology has also been central to challenging prejudice, understanding discrimination and developing culturally responsive interventions.
The appropriate conclusion is not that psychology is inherently colonial.
It is that psychological knowledge has a history, and that history matters for evaluating its concepts, institutions and authority.
The crucial distinction: Culture as a variable versus culture as a foundation
This is where the debate becomes especially interesting.
Three approaches to culture in psychology
LEVEL 1
Culture as an external variable
Culture influences otherwise universal psychological processes.
LEVEL 2
Culture as a constitutive context
Psychological processes develop through cultural practices, meanings and relationships.
LEVEL 3
Culture as a source of psychological theory
Different civilisational traditions may offer distinctive concepts of personhood, consciousness, wellbeing and moral development.
The third approach is particularly relevant to Indian and Dharmic thought.
Rather than asking only whether Indian culture influences psychological behaviour, psychologists could investigate what Indian intellectual traditions contribute to theories of mind, self, consciousness, emotion, attachment, compassion and ethical development.
Buddhist psychology, Jain philosophical accounts of passions and self-discipline, and Indian traditions of contemplative practice offer potentially rich resources.
These should be critically examined, rather than automatically accepted as scientific theories.
Is psychology changing?
Yes, and significantly.
Several established research traditions already challenge culturally narrow psychology.
Cultural psychology, associated with scholars such as Richard Shweder, Hazel Markus and Shinobu Kitayama, investigates how mind and culture mutually shape one another.
Cross-cultural psychology compares psychological processes across populations, including testing the generality of psychological theories.
Indigenous psychology, associated with scholars including Uichol Kim and Virgilio Enriquez, seeks to develop psychological knowledge grounded in local histories, languages and cultural experiences.
Community psychology examines individuals within social systems, power relationships and community environments.
Critical psychology questions the political, institutional and ideological assumptions of psychological research and practice.
Therefore, it would be inaccurate to say psychologists collectively reject culture.
The more defensible criticism is that culturally sophisticated psychological scholarship has not always transformed the assumptions, methods and professional training of the discipline as a whole.
What does this mean for finance and business education?
The parallels are striking.
| Psychology | Finance |
|---|---|
| Universal psychological individual | Universal rational economic agent |
| Culture as an influence on behaviour | Culture as an influence on financial decisions |
| Standardised psychological scales | Standardised financial metrics |
| Experimental control | Mathematical abstraction |
| Psychological wellbeing as measurable outcomes | Financial success as measurable returns |
| Cultural psychology challenges universalism | Organic Finance challenges universalism |
Both disciplines face the danger of confusing methodological simplification with the full reality of human experience.
However, there is an important difference.
Psychology has developed extensive intellectual traditions that place culture at the centre of inquiry. Finance has relevant work in economic sociology, institutional economics, behavioural finance and anthropology, but culturally constitutive approaches remain less prominent in mainstream technical finance education.
This creates an opportunity for dialogue between cultural psychology and Organic Finance.
Five scholars particularly worth examining
1. Richard Shweder — Cultural psychology, moral pluralism and the relationship between psychological knowledge and cultural worlds.
2. Hazel Markus — Culture, self-construal, motivation and the cultural construction of agency.
3. Shinobu Kitayama — Culture and cognition, emotion, motivation and interdependent selfhood.
4. Joseph Henrich — Cultural evolution, WEIRD populations and the historical development of psychological differences.
5. Jerome Bruner — Narrative, meaning-making and the importance of culture in human psychology.
For foundational reading, I would particularly recommend Acts of Meaning by Jerome Bruner (1990), alongside Henrich, Heine and Norenzayan’s 2010 paper The Weirdest People in the World?
A deeper conclusion
The challenge for psychology is not merely to become more culturally sensitive.
Cultural sensitivity may still assume that psychology possesses a universal scientific framework to which cultural differences must be added.
The deeper challenge is to recognise that culture participates in creating the very psychological realities that psychology seeks to explain.
And there is an even more demanding question:
Could diverse cultures and civilisations contribute new psychological concepts, rather than merely supply new populations for testing existing Western theories?
That is where psychology, Dharmic philosophy and Organic Finance share an important intellectual frontier.
The most powerful conclusion is this: Psychology cannot fully understand the human mind while treating the cultural worlds that give it meaning as secondary.
The same argument applies to finance: it cannot fully understand money while marginalising the beliefs, relationships and moral worlds through which money acquires meaning.